What We Learned From Prem Week 15


Baby, Baby, Baby, Where Did Our Defence Go?

Twas the night before Christmas, when all through the house Not a creature was stirring, not even a defender

For the first time in the history of the Prem everyone’s defence went missing, with a record number of goals scored and not one single team in the top flight  able to keep a clean sheet. Not one. And rather than being a sign of a growing attack minded tactical development in the league, or even an increase in genuine attacking quality as Match of the Day would have it, it’s yet another example of the continuing decline in quality of football in the Prem. Personally, I can’t think of a single Prem defender who can be realistically called world class, certainly none who are of the stature achieved by, say, Fabio Cannavaro during the 2006 World Cup or Barcelona’s Carlos Puyol during the last World Cup. The only one who even comes close is Chelski’s Ashley Cole and even he isn’t having the best of seasons.

If you look at the defensive records of the various Prem teams, none are particularly good. Admittedly there are few surprises, the four best defences belong to, guess who, the top four teams, while the worst three are West Ham, Wolves and, a little surprisingly, Blackpool, which doesn’t bode well for the Seasiders. But, let’s face it, none of the big four have a defence that has even the shallowest sheen of defensive impregnability as this Goals Conceded extract from the table tells us.

  1. Chelsea – 10
  2. Man City – 12
  3. Man U – 16
  4. Arsenal – 17

You sense that the Prem is really missing the likes of Viera, Keane (Roy not Robbie), Makelélé and Carvalho, who’ve left or retired (or in the case of Viera, effectively retired while still picking up Prem style wages – a good trick if you can manage it). Meanwhile, it’s clear that former defensive giants Rio, Vidic, Titface, Carragher, Touré and Sol Campbell are past their best to varying degrees, increasingly lacking pace and bedevilled by long-term injuries. And who are we replacing them with? Ivanovic and Alex at Chelsea? Evans and Smalling at Man U? The perma-injured Vermaelen and Koscielney at Arsenal? Kompany and Kolo Touré at Man City? None of these screams defensive invulnerability to me. Those championing defenders from teams like Bolton, Everton and Boremingham would do well to look at their overall defensive record before bigging them up too much.

It’s not clear what the solution to this is. Man City aside, few clubs want to spend big on a defender and it’s far from clear that the clubs are capable of training youngsters to be anything other than hoofing clumpers, barely capable of holding their own in the Prem, and utterly unsuited to the European game.

Crikey That World Cup Hangover Is Still With Me

It’s no wonder that clubs hate the international game with a vengeance. And not simply because it hijacks their best players and delivers them back tired, crocked or otherwise damaged (so much for building your side around a particular player), but because of the lingering, long-term effects of tournaments like the World Cup. If you look at the effect of winning it on, say, Torres, Fabregas, Reina and Barcelona it’s clear that there is a considerable World Cup hangover, a combination of having achieved your overwhelming footballing ambition and the kind of deep seated tiredness (both physical and mental) that comes with having played competitive top flight football almost continuously for the best part of four years, Spain having played through Euro 2008, the Confederations Cup and World Cup 2010.

Is it any wonder that the likes of Torres, Fabregas, Van Persil, Greedy Stevie, The Drog, Titface, Lumpy, Rio and Chav Wanker are clearly still struggling with form and susceptible to injuries? Or that World Cup absentees who had the summer off like Nasri or were merely bit part players like Van De Vaart, two of the few real highlights of this Prem season, have come into their own?

So All The Games Were Garbage Then?

Weeeeeeelll. No. Not in so many words. Man City‘s thoroughly tedious, if predictable, draw at Stoke aside, most of the games were thoroughly enjoyable in a desperate unsophisticated kick and rush Prem style. And even this match had two moments of real class. Micah Richards, who has beefed up to almost Balotelli proportions, displayed an unusually deft piece of footwork, turning his marker on the edge of the area, to score Man City’s, while a sweet backheel from Tuncay played Etherington in for Stoke’s equaliser. One benefit of flat, unmoving defences is that quick flicks will stun them much more effectively than long hoof-n-hopers, but two good moments in 90 minutes is hardly a ringing endorsement of Prem quality.

Fat Sam once again enhanced his self-inflated Engerland credentials by taking his Real Blackburn to Man U and rolling over in even more spectacular fashion than they did at Liverpool the other week. And they didn’t even have the excuse of missing their ‘big man’ Samba. However, it’s well known that Fat Sam always rolls over for Ferguson, so it was no surprise. And Man U did their best to take advantage, spanking Real at every opportunity, Berbatov getting five, two of which were the sort of lucky tap ins that most days would be easily saved or blocked. Nani looks to be increasingly like a gamechanging player. Chav Wanker looks to be retreating into that Paul Scholes role in midfield, which wouldn’t necessarily be a bad thing for him.

Arsenal did their best to put aside a pretty frightful week (losing to both Tottingham in the prem and Braga in the Big Cup) by putting the boot into Aston Villa. It was, in many ways, a typical Arsenal performance, they totally dominated the first half but only managed to score twice, then conspired to almost kneecap themselves by letting Villa get back into the game. Still they showed great resolve to grab the initiative and make it 1-3 almost immediately after Villa scored and it was nice to see Wilshere get his first Prem goal for the club. And while it was clear they are defending from the front, with both Song and Wilshere covering in midfield, the defence still looks very shakey. Still, two points behind the leaders, level with Chelski, with the fourth best defence in the Prem and seven points ahead of supposed super team Tottingham, that’s a crisis that most teams would be happy to have. Villa, meanwhile, who have a more serious crisis, have to decide whether they’re going to genuinely trust in the youngsters, which would be exciting and, probably, effective over time, but won’t get you short term results.

Chelski conspired to shoot themselves in the foot, what with Alex and Cech conspiring to conjure a Newcastle goal out of a simple backpass, losing the top spot in the Prem for the first time this season. Their tame draw at Newcastle exposed a side that seems to have completely lost its way. The previously formidable force of Malouda, Anelka and The Drog seems to be as threadbare as an overwalked carpet. It’s clear that without Essien in midfield Chelski are far less effective. Newcastle look certain to maintain their position in the Prem, which is what they were aiming for at the start of the season.

Apparent champions of North London (even if they’re still seven points behind Arsenal), Tottingham reaffirmed their new-found Big Four arrivista credentials by comfortably beating the dead dog (and former Big Four member) that is Liverpool Redsox. Spurs at White Hart Lane seem to be riding a wave of euphoria and adrenalin, and while they keep conceding the lead you get the sense that they just don’t want to lose, hence Lennon’s injury time winner. And while Torres was far better, some of his flicks and dinks were right lovely, he can’t make up for the many, many inadequacies of this Liverpool team.

Having had to eat our words regarding the former strike drought known as Elmander, we’ve going to have to take back our description of Bolton as ‘ a rancid sick sack of tedium and defensive hoofery’. Playing an ebullient Blackpool, who are always great value for money, it was as if the tables had been turned. If you’d said one of these teams would score two from set pieces and one would score two great goals, no one would have guessed that it would be the Seasiders who got a couple from corners and plucky Bolton who scored two fantastic goals. The second, especially, a combination of four great passes in the penalty area was a thing of rare beauty.

Everton continued their slide into mediocrity by meekly lying down to West Brom. It’s symptomatic of the stress around the club that Arteta was sent off for stamping and Cahill was caught raking his studs down the calf of one of his opponents.West Brom showed the form that did for Arsenal. It’s just a shame they can only managed it on a ‘once a month’ basis.

Fulham again managed to scrape a draw out of a potential defeat at home to Boremingham. Like Everton they lack any kind of a strikeforce capable of unlocking even these poor quality defences. Boremingham play away looking for draws, but it was nice to see Hleb dribbling about again.

Down at the dustbin of relegation, West Ham apparently ‘saved’ their season by narrowly stuffing a terrifyingly bad Wigan side shorn of its strikeforce through suspension. Scott Parker aside, it’s hard to see where the quality is going to come from for the ‘Appy ‘Ammers. Just as Tottingham seem to have inherited much of the FA Cup winning Portsmouth side, so West Ham seem to have been landed with the detritus of the  ‘relegated last year’ Portsmouth side, who appeared promising but still went down. There’s no evidence that any of them have improved over the past 12 months and it may be that any promise from Piquionne et al will garner the same results.

Even tardy tackling Wolves were up on the scoresheet against Sunderland, who are fast losing the shine from their win over Chelski a while ago. And they even won. And they were without captain and inadequate tackler Henry. Coincidence? I don’t think so. However, like West Ham they still find themselves 3 points adrift from safety.  And like West Ham, Everton, Wigan, Fulham and Aston Villa (coincidentally the teams immediately around them) it’s unclear where their goals are going to come from. And with no attack and useless defences, where does that leave the Prem?

Rob Green Save Of The Week

I keep almost fogetting this bit, what with keepers preferring to actually, well, keep properly. Again there was no one goalkeeping howler that really slapped you around the face. Instead we have the genius that is Real Blackburn’s Pascal Chimbonda with a backpass so weak and feeble that it made Alex’s mistake look like the epitome of great defending. As the ball meekly made its way to the edge of the box Berbatov was able to not only pounce on it, but spend a moment looking somewhat bemused in that kind of ‘I am still onside aren’t I?’ way before realising that, obviously, he was onside and calmly slotting it past Robinson for his second and Man U’s 3rd.


What We Learned From Prem Week 14


Never Mind The Quality, Feel The Width

It was a bad week for the big teams in London, in fact a bad week for all the teams in London unless you’re Tottingham, who out-thought, outfought and generally outdid an Arsenal side who seem to have thought that the game had finished after 45 minutes. It was a great week for Man U, who not only managed to hold on to a win against a reduced-to-9-men Wigan, rising to joint top of the table in the process, but saw the dubious return of Chav Wanker. Indeed, with Man City finally scoring goals again it was an excellent week for both sides of Manchester.

But the overall impression is that this season manages to intertwine two narrative strands. The first is that for a variety of reasons, the impending UEFA Financial Fair Play rules, the UK tax laws and the introduction of the 25 man Premiership squad among them, the quality of players in the Prem has diminished. Few genuinely world class players have arrived (and remember Real Madrid were desperate to offload Van der Vaart), while the few we had have been diminished. The second, possibly the result of the first, is that the quality of football of the best sides has declined. And with some of the trailing pack, Tottingham, Bolton, Man City among them, improving, the league has become more competitive, if only on a lower, more mediocre level.

The result means that no team is running away with the title. Yet despite ‘Appy ‘Arry saying that the Prem is more open than ever, the top 4 will undoubtedly come from the top six teams (or being really honest five of the top six as Bolton won’t make it beyond the Europa League places). The bottom two look set in stone. And the midtable stodge is greater than ever. Witness the lack of enthusiasm for Monday’s Sunderland Everton tie. Witness the lack of Prem players in the Ballon d’Or shortlist, which also contains no English players at all.

As further evidence of the decline in Prem standards consider the chances for English teams in the Big Cup. With Chelski out of form, Man U playing well below their previous high standards, Arsenal being defensively incompetent and Tottingham an unknown quantity, does anyone really expect an all-English final, or even two teams in the semis unless they get the luck of the draw?

Holy Moley, Is There Any Good News (Or Should I Just Kill Myself Now)?

I guess the third narrative strand is that we’re beginning to see an emergence of new, young talent, and I don’t mean the long-awaited promised land of a successful Arsenal side. It’s almost as if we’re witnessing the end of a sclerotic period of overblown excess as high priced, old has-beens are shuffled off into the sunset in favour of cheaper, younger, possibly less proven youngsters taking their places. Aston Villa under Houllier are blowing away the logjam imposed by Martin O’Neil, Chelski are regularly fielding two or three young players on their bench if not their first team, while Arsenal have seen Wilshere break his way into the team.

Games, Games, Games

If there’s one thing we’ve really learnt this week, it’s that Arsenal aren’t likely to win anything soon, but this is nothing really new. Their capitulation to a buoyant Tottingham side tells us what we’ve all known for years, they are mentally weak, lack leadership on the field and have no idea how to defend. Going forward they are immaculate. Certainly their forward play in the first half was beautiful, their goals splendid, but once again they showed a defensive naivety exhibited only by the likes of Wolves and West Ham. It’s unclear what the problem is, but Wenger clearly has some kind of a mental block where defending, or defensive coaching is concerned. I can’t think of a genuinely world class central defender playing for Arsenal since the Adams Winterburn partnership Wenger inherited when he arrived. Oh alright, possibly Sol Campbell. But since then, nada. And Vermaelen doesn’t count because he’s now as crocked as Van Persil.

This weekend Tottingham’s midweek Big Cup opponents Werder Bremen were caned  4-0 by the aptly named, if 15th in the table, Shalke 04. Their similarity to Arsenal, the presence of useless defender Mickael Silvestre, who was way past his best  well before he left Man U to become another stopgap Arsenal defender. The list of mediocre Arsenal central defenders under Wenger is a sad and sorry tale, typified by what regulars call The Senderos Years, and the purchase over the summer of low graders like Squillachi (at 30 obviously yet another stopgap signing) and Koscielny (who clearly is having trouble adapting to the Prem). It’s clear that Wenger needs to do what so many have called for for years, buy one or two genuinely experienced, on-field leaders to bring his team forward.

Tottingham, by contrast, are flying. Albeit with fewer points than Arsenal and a defence that is every bit as pourous and inept as Arsenal’s. Their recent matches against Inter, Bolton and Blackburn have been rip-roaring occasions, if only because Spurs regularly give their opponents a couple of goals for starters. When asked what lessons he had learnt after their 4-3 pasting/Bale inspired fightback at the San Siro, you sensed that Redknapp’s only answer should have been, “don’t give Inter a 4 goal lead”. Will they win the league this season? No chance, not least because if they make it into the latter stages of the Big Cup they will hit the wall hard. Will they remain in the top 4? It’s between them, Man City and Arsenal for the last two places.

Meanwhile, Chelski continue to implode. How much of a twat does Essien feel for that inane two footed leap at Clint Dempsey in the 93rd minute which got him a straight red and a 3 match ban? Because without him, Titface, and Lumpy, Chelski’s spine is looking very dubious. Certainly new boy Ramires and Mikel aren’t a solid midfield spine. And it’s clear that a below par Drog playing against a notoriously solid defence is not the attacking threat he might be.  Boremingham have built on their umpteen low grade, low score draws and have a reliable strong defence and a stunning ability to spot goalkeeping talent – last year they got Joe Hart on loan, this year they have Ben Foster. And as Arsenal have found to their cost, a good keeper will save you points in the key, big games, while a bad one will just concede goals.

Man U kept on keeping on. Playing badly and winning. And they were aided by some chaotic playing by Wigan, who did themselves no favours by having two players sent off for inept, catastrophically poor fouls. Not even the appearance of the newly bemoneyed Chav Wanker could lift this match above mediocre.

Surprise package Bolton managed to do what neither Man U not Arsenal could, played well and won. Winning being a euphemism for ‘giving Newcastle a right good stuffing’. Lovely to see Kevin Nolan give away the first penalty. And once again Elmander played a blinder and scored twice.

Man City also appeared to have unblocked themselves and suffered a discharge of goals. And in a beautiful moment of hubris it was former manager Mark Hughes and his Fulham team who were on the receiving end. They still look like a work in progress, but they will be in contention for the Europa Little Cup and the top four.

Blackpool continue to surprise and astonish. A beneficiary of the downgrading of Prem quality, they have phenomenal team spirit and odd moments of genius. Their first goal against a shambolic Wolves reinforced Blackpool’s notions of style over hoofery and Wolves’ disturbing habit of conceding in the first 10 minutes. Blackpool might not win anything, but they’re more likely to stay up than Wolves are and they’re way, way better to watch.

Liverpool continue to surprise and astonish. Sure they gave a shambolic West Ham a right good spanking, but there’s nothing there. Most interestingly, they won easily without Greedy Stevie. Is he going to just walk back into the side in a month’s time if they continue to win?

Down in the stodge of mid-table mediocrity, up and comers Stoke continued their nice progress by beating a fast-falling West Brom side. Still the latter needn’t worry. There are at least three teams starting with W who are worse than they are in the Prem. Even Real Blackburn managed a win, albeit against a youthful, experimental Villa side. And either Everton or Sunderland could get a really big 3 points this evening. But more likely the dour defence of the former will overcome the Chelsea win enthused attack of the latter. Expect Darren Dullboy Bent to replace Asamoah Gyan with his usual toothless charm.

Rob Green Save Of The Day

No question of the winner this week. After all, with Engerland keepers Ben Foster and, incredibly, Rob Green having good days, there was only one place to go. Once again the Entire Arsenal Defence wins for their complete inability to defend a simple ‘hoof it to the big man’ gambit from Spurs. The sight of the entire defensive line coagulating around Defoe as the ball sped on its merry way to an unmarked Bale was as emotionally devastating as it was funny. This lot could lose a one person fight with themselves. In the dark. With one hand tied behind their backs.


What We Learned From Prem Week 13


When You Are Tired Of Football, You Are Tired Of Life

True, I may not be completely tired, but I am somewhat exhausted. Three full weeks of Prem in 9 days has taken it out of me and, it would seem, the teams and players. How else can you explain the events of Week 13? How else can you explain that no one, not one team, managed to score 3 wins? The best attempt being  from mid-table mediocrities Bolton and Sunderland, who both took a commendable 7 points. And, yes, I know that the best teams should be used to playing weekends and midweeks, but there was something about having a full set of Prem matches midweek that seems to have piled on the pressure. And not in a good way.

The result? A plethora of nil-nils of various shapes and sizes and more draws than we’ve seen since the middle of October. Sure there were some upsets, but they too seem to be the result of overload as much as ambition on the part of the victors (and make no mistake there was ambition in places). But now we’ve got an international week and everyone can take a break as top stars pull out of ‘meaningless friendlies’ with an assortment of strategic niggles, knocks and pulls. Naturally, all will be fit again come next Saturday.

Evolution Or Revolution?

That said, it has been interesting seeing how teams have been developing over the course of the season so far. And this season that development has  seemed more apparent than ever. Just as teams grow into World Cups and European Championships, so teams in the Prem have to adapt and grow as the season progresses to take advantage of the strengths and weaknesses of both themselves and others. Take how Wolves have evolved from dour hack and kick merchants to vaguely pacey wingplayers as Hunt and Jarvis come into fitness and form. Or how Sunderland have adapted their play to the talents of Asamoah Gyan as Darren Bent has been injured. And if the story of this week is about anything its about the effects of these little revolutionary adaptations. Certainly those teams that are seizing the day are being rewarded.

Gimmie Games

Possibly the best example of both the exhausting effects of the last 9 days and the evolution of teams was the Chelski Sunderland tie. Chelski, fresh off an away slapping from the Liverpool Redsox and a home win against Fulham, looked like a spent force, the heart might have been willing but there was nothing left in the tank. And in some cases there was little evidence that the heart was there either. With Essien out of their midfield there appears to be little backbone there, Ramieres being somewhat spindly while Obi Mikel still appears more lumbering than lethal. Add to that a makeshift central defence and you’ve got a recipe for trouble. Still with The Drog, Anelka, Malouda, Cole, Bosingwa and Cech in the side they should still be formidable. And yet they were thoroughly bossed by a Sunderland team who’d been utterly destroyed by Newcastle earlier in the month. Playing two up front and harrying Chelski mercilessly, Sunderland showed that Chelski, like Arsenal, don’t appear to enjoy it when sides take the game to them, pressing them all over the pitch, denying them time and space in their own half. And with Onuoha’s outstanding ‘dribble through the defence’ goal we saw the first signs of a defensive collapse at Chelski.

Some have suggested that Chelski’s problems stem from their summer ship out of ailing and aging former greats, citing the presence of youngsters like McEachran, Kakuta and Van arnolt on the bench as evidence of their less capable extended team, but I disagree. Sure they’ve lost Bollocks, Deco, Joke Cole, and Carvalho, but it’s only the latter who seems to be genuinely missed, being the outstanding defensive mainstay alongside Titface for a number of seasons. The rest aren’t pulling up trees in their new clubs and seem to be spending more time on the treatment table than the pitch to be honest.

The real kudos has to go to Steve Bruce for tactically outsmarting Chelski with his attacking two up front line up and to Gyan, Onuoha and Wellbeck for taking their goals so well. Make no mistake Sunderland have got over the psychological damage of that Newcastle result and have inflicted considerable psychic pain on Chelski too.  Chelski’s next match, away to Boremingham looks like it could be pretty tasty.

The only sad thing for Sunderland was that Onuoha’s goal won’t be Goal of the Season as, astonishingly, it wasn’t even Goal of the Week. That was Bolton‘s second against Wolves. Now previously we may have given the impression that Elmander was a useless waste of space who couldn’t score if he was given an open goal, but here he gave an impression of Messi-like omnipotence as he danced his way through an apparently impenetrable box of four Wolves defenders, none of whom was more than a yard away from him, with some dazzling footwork before sliding the ball into the corner of the net. And with an Arsenal-like defence splitting threesome pass-pass-shoot move from Davies, Lee and Holden for their third, Bolton look like a team transformed. Another case of genuine evolution over the course of the season so far. Wolves, too, look far superior to the  side that was being savaged (and doing the savaging) earlier this season. Admittedly, it doesn’t seem to have done them any good as they still have the worst form in the league and are really down among the dead men, but they have just played all the big teams in the last month. With this form, all they need is someone to slot the ball into the net with something approaching regularity and they should be OK.

If Elmander’s goal was a treat, Stoke‘s first against Liverpool Redsox was a return to the primary school playground. A horrorshow, from Liverpool’s point of view, saw the ball ricochet around the penalty area as pretty much the whole Redsox team went awol, chasing the ball around the box like demented, unsophisticated eight year-olds as first one then another Stoke striker tried to gamely force it into the net. Eventually Pocket Drog Ricardo Fuller toe poked it in to pile on the misery for unambitious Uncle Wroy and his boys, leaving them just 3 points above the dropzone. How this drab, ineffective team beat Chelski is a real mystery.

No mystery to how Arsenal managed to beat Everton. As Phil Neville said, “we just couldn’t boss them”. This time Arsenal won, if not dirty, then certainly muddied and unbowed as they pressed Everton around the pitch and didn’t allow the home side to pressurise them. In the midst of this they took advantage of Everton’s defensive lapses. Their second goal, while not as classically Arsenal as Bolton’s third, was a masterpiece of close footplay, taking out the entire Everton defence in three lethal passes. Possibly the most interesting element of the whole match was the way Arsenal players kept going “Come On!” to their teammates, an indication that, to them, this match really mattered.

Tottingham seem to have got over their post-European blues (about bloody time) as they gave Fat Sam’s Real Blackburn a right good thumping. As they say Real were lucky to only concede four as Spurs missed a hatful of chances and a penalty and gave them two gimmie goals at the end to make Real feel less thoroughly spanked. The notion that Fat Sam might either, manage Engerland, or, successfully manage in Europe, seems like the height of folly and delusion. Oh wait, it was the height of folly and delusion.

Villa‘s own evolutionary project seems to be coming on apace, aided by injuries to useless lumpen forwards Donkey and Carew. Certainly Agbonlahor’s return and his link up play with Ashley Young seems to have sparked the pair into life. And aided by a cohort of new, young players, they gave Man U a seriously painful time before rather predictably giving away a two goal lead in the last ten minutes. When even your manager says, “When I saw them score the first, I knew they’d score a second”, it’s not a ringing endorsement of progress to date.

In the only other three point thriller (oh alright three point slumber), Wigan just about did enough to beat a West Brom team that doesn’t seem to know where it’s going. One week they’re great, beating Arsenal away and moving to 5th in the table, the next they’re playing poorly and losing to an ineffective also-ran side.  On this evidence, both teams look set to struggle.

No goals in the remaining three matches, but what a contrast in style, ambition and verve. West Ham‘s match against Blackpool was a masterpiece of ambition, character and enthusiasm over skill and effectiveness, with apparently 45 shots only 4 of which were judged to be on target.  Truly this was primo knockabout stuff, with Blackpool, as always, going for it and West Ham desperate for some kind of point-related lifeline. However, neither had the skill to really make an impact, and when they did, eventually, have shots on target, their respective keepers were more than up to the challenge.

In total contrast, Man City‘s dour draw with Boremingham was as tedious as the most dreary Italian catenaccio ever. You have to worry that, in a week when Steve Bruce dared to take the game to Chelski away from home and came away with three points, the height of Dullberto Mancini’s ambition seems to have been to take a point at home from Boremingham, who are themselves the very definition of unambitious. Admittedly, this is a man who threw away a top four finish last year when he lost at home to fellow challengers Tottingham in May by playing far, far too defensively. And having spent something in the region of a grazillion pounds revamping that team, he still finds that he has no significant attacking options beyond Carlos Tevez. Just think City could have been playing Inter Milan in the Big Cup this season if only Mancini had some bollocks.

Finally, Fulham‘s nil-niller at Newcastle was a case of both teams running out of steam at the end of this gruelling three match/nine day period. While exhibiting more skill and control than either West Ham or Blackpool, neither team could manufacture that killer blow. Once again, Fulham’s goose-shit green strip failed to do anything more than make them look anonymous and lost all over the pitch. Newcastle, meanwhile, missed the skill of the suspended Joey Barton, which is really damning them with faint praise.

Rob Green Save Of The Day

With exhaustion dogging the heels of every keeper, there wasn’t really any one standout goalline fuckup. Sure, both Wolves’ contribution to Bolton’s first, a spectacularly headed own goal, and Real Blackburn’s contribution to Tottingham’s third, were taken into consideration, but both appeared to be more the result of fine pressing from the attacking team than actual keeping catastrophes. No, the real winner has to be the entire Liverpool Redsox team for their comic efforts to stop Stoke’s first goal. As pretty much the whole team rushes about the box like extras in the under attack Star Trek command centre, now to the left, now to the right, Reina is left as little more than a spectator, feeling, as you would, that with about 9 of his own players slap bang in front of him the ball can’t possibly get through. By the time he sees it it’s in the back of the net.


What We Learned From Prem Week 12


If A Week’s A Long Time In Politics…

Then it’s an absolute age in Football. This week sees the Prem attempt to compress 3 weeks worth of fixtures into 9 days, with all the intensity of a small child stuffing too many sweets into its overstretched maw. Truly the Prem’s eyes are bigger than its stomach, but what the hell, next week’s an International week and we will be having no Prem, so best to stuff up on it now in the hope that we will be able to sustain ourselves over the barren wilderness of Euro 2012 qualifiers and friendlies.

The Prem Is Like A Rapidly Balding Old Geezer

The Prem after week 12. Hmmmm. Look at all that flabby white underbelly.

Formed in 1992, the Prem has entered its grizzly adolescence, but seems to be showing dangerous signs of advancing rapidly to some kind of toxic middle age. Most noticeably there seems to be something of a thinning on the top and a distinct bulge around the middle. This is due to an increase in what the new American owners of Liverpool have termed ‘Stodgeball’, overweight, flabby football that owes little to innovation, tactics or skill but is rather the side effect of clubs remaining in the Prem bereft of any ambition other than to avoid relegation. Stodgeball gives us untidy unwatchable matches between journeyman teams like Sunderland, Bolton and, it must be said, the New Liverpool, packed with little action and few moments of real joy. And like some self-conscious old duffer, the Prem is trying hard to conceal its rapidly growing paunch of mediocrity, in their case behind a wardrobe of extra large Super Sunday / Wonderful Wednesday branded sports attire. But as they say, the table never lies.

Just below that deadly layer of flab is what doctors call the ‘silent killer’, a layer of teams either struggling to come to terms with the division, say Blackpool, or barely adequate to hover above the relegation zone, boredraw specialists, ineffective in attack and relatively incompetent in defence. Content only that there are three teams marginally less able than themselves.

It’s Boredraws Ahoy!

For the first time this season it appeared that the entire Prem had locked itself into some kind of psychic constipation, unable to move beyond a torrid stalemate of attritional midfield tedium. And while a few games did manage to provide results – curiously enough many were resolved only in the last 10 minutes – there seems to have been an overabundance of draws this week. And as both Mans United and City are finding, draws aren’t going to be enough, you need to have the balls to try to win matches if you want to win anything. Just look at Tottingham, who have the perfect record, played 12, won 4, drawn 4, lost 4 and have significantly more points than if they had simply drawn all their matches. Man U are undefeated, but have only one more point than Arsenal, who have already lost three times, due to all those tedious draws they were snatching (or conceding) earlier in the season. Meanwhile, Boremingham, who with 12 points would actually be better off if they had drawn all their games (as their goal difference would be 0 rather than -3), sit just above the relegation zone.

Man U might consider a draw from a visit to Middle Eastlands and Man City a decent result, seeing as they were stuffed there a few years back, but that was before City went all nouveau riche on us and hit that embarrassing adolescence all developing teams hit when they feel that actually winning is somehow awkward and clumsy. Certainly if City are going to hold on to that fourth Big Cup place, they’re going to actually have to go out an try and win matches rather than being content with not losing them. Man U have to hope that both Chav Wanker and Valencia come back to something approaching fitness soon if they want to challenge for the top.

Arsenal continue to show all the signs of emergent schizophrenia. Following his shite performance against the big man of Newcastle, FlappyHanski showed that there is a great goalie in there by denying a forceful Wolves for the whole 94 minutes. And while he’s still not commanding his area in the way that the best keepers do, there was a vague sense of competence at the back of the Arsenal defence. Meanwhile, their attack is still operating on the principle that a return of one goal in 8 gilt-edged chances is somehow an acceptable return.

Chelski pushed on with a wholly average win over Fulham. Their paint by numbers win was marred only by Essien’s two footed leap at Clint Dempsey, who had previously elbowed Bosingwa in the head, and the continued presence of the useless Kalou, who must rival Arsenal’s Bentner for most irritating 4th choice striker. Surely Chelski have better players in their locker somewhere.

Tottingham continue to drag themselves further from next year’s Big Cup by managing to utterly dominate Sunderland before gifting them a goal and a point. It’s clear that even with a goal a game at home, Van der Vaart can’t camouflage Spurs’ defensive ineptitude. With Bale and the rest looking thoroughly contained by a barely adequate Sunderland team, that win against Inter is starting to look more and more like a millstone around Tottingham’s neck than a starting point for better things.

Stoke finally won. Although they only just managed to beat a tepid Boremingham, who are going to have to learn not to give away leads to their opponents before getting their act together (or not in the case of this match).

West Ham went 2 – 1 up against West Brom, before, yet again, realising that they are crap and conceding a goal. They seem to have a problem with the last 30 minutes of matches, conceding goals and games repeatedly. Although in their defence it must be said they also have a problem with much of the first 60 minutes of matches. They’re interesting because, like Wolves, you feel that there are 3 sides who are playing consistently worse football but with better results (I name you Blackburn, Wigan and Sunderland).

Speaking of Wigan, they managed to put the kybosh into the Liverpool Redsox story. You have to say that without Gerrard, Torres and Riena, Liverpool would be down and out among the dead men. They have a pisspoor back four, have hemorrhaged midfield creativity in the last two years (goodbye to Alonso and Mascherano, hello to Joke Cole, Poulson and Moreles) and have no one capable of deputising for Torres. They were lucky to scrape a draw here. In a continuation of the attendance malaise raised in Prem Week 11 Wigan’s stadium was barely two thirds full with 3,691 people fewer watching this match than the Championship match between  Leicester and Sheffield United.

Newcastle continued their fine record at home by losing to Real Blackburn. Their tactic of pumping it to the big man outdone by the fact that Fat Sam has more than enough big men of his own to mark and harry Carroll. Although obviously they didn’t bother to do anything sensible like mark or harry him for his goal. Newcastle did help them by having what can only be described as ‘a right pair of defensive fuckups’, which gifted Real their goals.

Everton continue to be their own worst enemy. They should have comfortably put Bolton to bed, but let them get ahead easily and then almost shot themselves in the foot by going down to 10 men, Fellani kicking out at Robinson after the latter had caught him in a nasty scissor tackle. Luckily for them they were able to claw a point back at the death.

Villa have to go down as the luckiest team this week. Despite being outplayed and outstyled for long periods by Blackpool, they managed to scrap a win from the jaws of drawdom with a last ditch set piece play. Blackpool continue to surprise, giving the impression that they are a team that not only enjoys their football, but is prepared to gamble on stylish backheels and through balls. They have a daring and ambition that Man City palpably lack. You wonder just what they would be like if Ian Holloway was in charge at Middle Eastlands. Maybe they’d have lost, maybe they’d have been stuffed, but maybe, just maybe, they’d have beaten the crap out of Man U.


What We Learned From Prem Week 11


Bad Weekend For The Capital

It’s almost become an annual fixture, it’s November, the clocks go back and the young shoots of promise that emerged so gloriously at Arsenal during the Carling Cup in October retreat back into their delicate wafer-thin shells for another year. Man U’s mid-range stars begin to establish themselves as serious contenders. And the top few continue to pull away from the also-rans.

Two things were clear this weekend. First the Mourinho Discipline is alive and well, proving unusually effective against two of the more talented sides. Both Liverpool and Newcastle pressed hard and denied their more skillful opponents the opportunity to play their game in midfield before retreating into a tight, impregnable defensive shells and winning the game on the break or with a well planned and executed free kick (from near the halfway line!).

Second, there is a very clear, massive gulf in interest between matches featuring the big teams (Man U, Arsenal, Chelski and Liverpool) and the rest. No fewer than six (out of ten) of the matches saw attendances of less than 27,000, with only one of them – Blackpool’s 16,094 – being close to capacity.  With over half the live audience watching only three matches (at Man U, Arsenal and Liverpool) and with only two of the remaining matches being even vaguely interesting, it’s clear that something is very wrong in the state of the Prem.

Hey Ho, It’s The Games

Half his hair is going white, the other half is staying resolutely dark. Chris Houghton demonstrates surprising dedication to the Toon

In probably the most predictable outcome of the weekend, a defensively inept team was outdone by close pressing and the dynamic work of a busy centre forward. But enough about Chelski‘s loss to Liverpool, this time we’re talking about Arsenal‘s lacklustre display at home to Newcastle. Having succumbed to The Drog’s bullying against Chelski, they promptly went into defensive incompetency against the free-running Andy Carroll, who is starting to look more and more like an intelligent and dangerous no 9. A truly appalling performance from a team at home who beat Newcastle 4 – 0 in the Little Cup only 11 days ago. From Arsenal’s point of view you can’t say this wasn’t coming as their previous matches against Birmingham and West Ham were hardly impressive displays, but when even Joey Barton can tactically outwit you it’s time to address the by now very familiar issues. Arsenal won’t win anything if their work off the ball is as sloppy as it was this week, if their defence is as useless as this and if their attack is as flimsy and ineffectual. Koscielny is going to have to shape up if he wants to continue at this level, having picked up his second red card of the season – this time a ‘take one for the team’ wrestle on Ranger, who had outpositioned him and would have been bearing down on goal. While the need for a genuinely world class keeper is more apparent than ever. Newcastle, meanwhile, are on a roll and aren’t going to get relegated this season. By the way, the best thing about Newcastle is the way that manager Chris Houghton’s hair is going grey in supercool Newcastle stripes.

Chelski on the other hand looked like a team who’ve lost the plot, or at least misplaced it on the road oop north. Unless there’s a really good reason, or you’re some kind of moron, you don’t leave The Drog on the bench for a key, statement match like this. Either he’s unable to play or you start him. And while Liverpool have been pretty tragic for most of the season, this week their two totemic players stepped up to the mark, Gerrard singlehandedly stuffing Napoli in midweek, while Torres emerged from his year-long hibernation to brutalise Chelski in much the same style that The Drog usually does to other, lesser sides. Two outstanding goals settled the game and Chelski looked completely bereft and unable to respond.  It used to be Arsenal who didn’t like to travel north, but now Chelski have lost two games away to Big Four challengers already this season and don’t look nearly as impregnable as they did a fortnight ago.

Man U‘s juggernaut just keeps on trucking, only this time it’s more like one of those trucks from Belgium that runs on potato fuel and trundles along the motorway at 45 spewing out pollution and holding up all the other traffic. Still it was enough to just about see off Wolves, who once again played a good game but were just too toothless up front to really do any damage. Man U have to prepare for the Manchester Derby on Wednesday, which looks like hard work for them while Wolves have got Arsenal at home on Wednesday, which should be a very interesting affair.


Man City’s close pressing game in midfield denied West Brom space and relied on patience to create the chances for Balotelli to score. It’s interesting to see how many of their balls into or around the box were unsuccessful.

by Guardian Chalkboards

West Brom, who’ve blown hot and cold so far this season, couldn’t hold out a dominating Man City. As the chalkboard above shows City dominated the midfield with their gargantuan players limiting West Brom to no shots at all, while Mario Balotelli put away two chances in the first half hour. He reminds me of an early stage Mike Tyson, he’s huge and relatively ungainly, but when he comes at you you just can’t stop him. And in much the same way that Tyson used to cruise through the first minute of a round before advancing like a tank on his opponent and obliterating him, so Balotelli waits a bit, then crushes your defence, and it’s game over. Sadly he seems to have inherited the same mental dis-equilibrium as Tyson and followed up his two goals with the sort of whining, petulant display that saw him sent off and will see him roundly loathed throughout English football (two dives in the box, some verbal abuse and a deliberate stamping).  More significantly for Man City, it means he will miss the Man U match on Wednesday, and that’s a big miss. If I were Mancini, I’d be having some serious chats with him and laying down the law.

Among the dreary matches which almost no one could be bothered to attend, let alone view on Match of the Day, Real Blackburn just about did for the unreliable Wigan, with Jason Roberts getting the goal that he should have scored against Chelski last week but was too afraid to. Blackpool led Everton twice before being immediately held back. Everton are going to have to learn that it’s worthwhile scoring goals before the other side if they want to progress up the table. West Ham led Boremingham by two goals before remembering that they’re supposed to be crap and letting two in. Fulham just about managed to hold a young, ineffective Aston Villa side with a late equaliser. And Sunderland sneaked it against Stoke thanks to two goals from Asamoah Gyan and the most blatant on the goalline handball since Dirty Suarez did his thing (this time against Gyan) in the World Cup courtesy of Cheating Crappermole. Stoke brought the game down with their own Crappermole clone Ryan Shawcross being sent off for another two incompetant challenges.

The only other interesting game saw Tottingham once more come to appreciate the psychological downside of the Big Cup. One day you’re at home giving a right good stuffing to the Kings of Europe, with stars in your eyes and that awful Champions League dirge ruining your ears, the next it’s a smelly coach trip to Bolton for a bloody scrap over three points in the Prem. And if you’re Gareth Bale, who ran yourself ragged in midweek to the applause of the good and the great of European soccer, it’s easy to appear in person, if not in footballing spirit, and be atrociously mediocre on the Saturday. The real danger for Spurs is that they won’t make it into the Big Cup next season on performances like this. And then it’s bye-bye Big Cup, hello more games like this.

Rob Green Save Of The Day

No challengers for this one, it’s a clear winner this week. Arsenal keeper FlappyHanski lived up to his made up name when he first came for, then paused, then attemtpted to go back and then jumped at Joey Barton’s long free kick into the area. It’s hard to believe that he is only 1cm shorter than Carroll and can use his hands when Carroll is so clearly almost a metre above him and heading the ball into his net. That’s three points that are going to hurt you Lukasz. But not as much as the headache you’ve just given Arsène Wenger.


What We Learned From Prem Week 10


Mind The Gap

Two themes manifest themselves this week. The first is ‘Class will out’, best illustrated by the late, relatively scrappy wins for Chelski and Arsenal and losses for Top Four challengers Tottingham and Man City. The second is that black is white, up is down, and right is wrong as manifested by both Man U’s morally indefensible second goal and Wolves’ win over Man City.

Prem week 10

Grinding out wins when you’re playing poorly is often cited as the hallmark of Championship (or Premiership) winning sides. Both Arsenal and Chelski pulled the points out of the hat by effective, attritional matches, thereby opening up a gap (along with Man U) over the rest of the Prem. It’s particularly interesting to look at the goal difference column in the table – only the top three have differences in double figures, while only three teams outside the top 5 even have positive goal differences – Newcastle’s boosted by their excellent thumping of Sunderland.

The tightness of the bottom twelve is illustrated by Liverpool’s leap to 12th – just two wins effectively pulling the reds out of trouble, and Everton’s elevation to 8th. Both were languishing in the bottom 4 only two weeks ago. Wolves have managed to pull themselves back into the mix thanks to their win, leaving West Ham in even more trouble. As far as relegation goes I’d happily take Blackburn, Wolves and West Ham to go down. Certainly anything that takes Fat Sam out of the picture can only be described as a good result.

However, the overwhelming impression from this week was that there weren’t any really standout matches, only Newcastle’s win showed any of the frenetic end-to-end kick and rush gameplay we’ve come to expect this season. All of which simply reinforces the view that the standard of play in the Prem has deteriorated significantly, especially compared to the best of the Champions League – certainly I haven’t seen a Prem match this season that compares with either Tottingham’s defeat to Inter or either of Arsenal’s home matches against Braga and Shakhtar Donetsk. You can argue that this just means that the Prem defences are harder to break down, but it’s sometimes hard to be bothered to watch.

What About The Games?

Chelski are looking more and more like total contenders. They can play stylish or they can play hardcore as they did against Real Blackburn. You just get a sense of solid capability running throughout the side, great defence, formidable midfield and, with The Drog and Anelka, a forward line that doesn’t seem to give in. And while Real were far, far better than they were against Liverpool, they didn’t have the cutting edge to really trouble Chelski. The first Chelski goal especially illustrated their versatility, a long punt from Cech, beautifully controlled by Maluda around the halfway line, was crossed for The Drog to head down to the onrushing Anelka to sidefoot in. Sweet, immediate and ruthless.

A ruthlessness Arsenal could well do with more of, their on-goal profligacy being something of legend. 13 shots on target for just one goal in return seems like an anaemic performance, but it doesn’t really tell the whole story. In this case it wasn’t so much Arsenal’s frivolity in front of goal, they have, after all scored 12 in their last 3 games, as the great performance from West Ham‘s Rob Green (who’d have thought eh?). But the pressure on West Ham’s goal, along with West Ham’s lack of firepower told in the end as Song headed in. The Hammers are looking increasingly like this year’s ‘too good to go down’ side, which would be a shame as there are plenty of teams who play less attractive fooball.

Man U might be having Chav Wanker related problems but they really don’t need too much help from refs. Tottingham gave them a bit of a game, but sadly didn’t ever look like menacing United, even before ref Clattenburg decided to let them have a patently unfair if vaguely legal goal (see below) . It was a bit demoralising to see a Spurs side, which on the face of it looked capable of challenging Man U, being overrun so comprehensively, none of their key players, Modric, Bale, Keane, or Crouch making any kind of impact whatsoever. Doubly demoralising to see Van De Vaart, Spurs’ outstanding player this season, being carted off with a hamstring injury.

Quite what Mick McCarthy said to Wolves this week is a mystery. The side that last week couldn’t score or defend properly and were a disgrace to football seem to have dispensed with the useless, incompetent challenges (that penalty aside) and ‘character building’ hoof-n-hopers in favour of fast, penetrating wingplay and great movement around the box. Which, along with the absence of Tevez from Man City, meant that they increasingly dominated this match and thoroughly deserved their win. It seems that while Wolves can’t get a point from the teams around them, they’re actually capable of taking apart the bigger teams. Who would have thought it, McCarthy’s a tactician and Man City are a one-man team. Are there three worse teams than Wolves in the Prem? On the basis of this performance, definitely yes. Are there four teams better than Man City? That’s a much bigger question. Now Wolves have shown other teams the way, it will be interesting to see how City perform against West Brom and then Man U in the next fortnight. Two more losses and it could be curtains for their Top Four hopes.

Premiership Wages 2008-09 season from the excellent Swiss Ramble

Down in the dumps of mid-table mediocrity, Fulham did for unpredictable Wigan with two class goals from Clint Dempsey, one of those relatively unheralded but dedicated gamechanging players. While Everton beat Stoke, who are fast looking like they’re running out of ideas. Certainly with Ricardo Fuller and Kenwyne Jones both being sub-10 goals a season strikers, it’s hard to see where their wins are going to come from. Equally, Everton only have two players, Cahill and Arteta who’ve scored more than once in the Prem this season. But top of the bores was Villa‘s utterly tedious goalless derby against Boremingham. Given Villa had the largest wage bill outside the top five only last year, it’s astonishing that they don’t have a forward line more capable than Heskey and Carew, who have a grand total of one league goal between them this season. How they are missing Agbonlahor.

How Liverpool are missing Fernando Torres. What’s that you say? He was playing against Bolton? Well you could have fooled me. Unless it was that imitation Torres we’ve been seeing since halfway through last season, the guy who looks like he’s been solely responsible for propping Liverpool up for a season and a bit and has been injured for the best part of a year, that Torres. And, yes, his nice backheel to set up Maxi Rodrigues for the goal was, well, nice. But Liverpool won more through the paucity of Bolton’s ambition than through any great skill of their own. Still grinding out wins when you’re not playing well is the hallmark of champions after all.

No one could accuse Newcastle of grinding out a result. They just hammered a very poor Sunderland side in the same way they mullered Aston Villa earlier this season. Landlord Superstar (and Captain) Kevin Nolan got a hattrick, while Shola Ameobi got two, one of them a cracking net-thrashing volley.  Sunderland didn’t seem to have the midfield ingenuity to deal with Newcastle’s core of Nolan, Carroll, Barton and Ameobi and were, once again, toothless in attack and defence.

Rob Green Save Of The Day

Green, again, had a good week, certainly keeping West Ham in the game against Arsenal until the 88th minute, although you could argue that he was badly positioned for the Arsenal goal. And there weren’t any spoons, slips or moments of arbitrary madness from keepers around the Prem either. So the Save Of The Day has to go to Hilarious Gomez of Spurs, who certainly didn’t see that Nani goal coming. That’s got to hurt.